Trading Practice5 min read

A Debrief Template for Practice Trades

Replay Trader Editorial Team

Educational content for Indian traders on deliberate practice, chart replay, and setup discovery. Not investment advice.

A debrief that takes twelve minutes will not survive a thirty-day practice block. You will skip it on the day you most need it — usually the day you broke a rule and the sim still printed green. The template has to be short enough to run while the urge to close the laptop is highest.

This is not a journal essay and not a weekly cinema review. Those have their place in how you review practice trades and in a classification journal. The debrief is the ninety-second layer that sits on each decision so the weekly review has raw material.

The five fields (FIT-UN)

Write them in this order. Do not add a sixth until you have used five for two weeks.

# Field What you write Allowed values
1 Frame Which rule set was active One setup name + NSE window (pullback / open)
2 Intent What you meant to do before the click enter / skip / manage
3 Tape Condition tag at decision time Closed list you wrote this week (drive / chop / unclear)
4 Urge What you wanted to do instead none / chase / revenge / boredom / peek
5 Next One mechanical tweak or hold-rule A single phrase, or the word hold-rule

Process score (0–2) sits beside FIT-UN. It is not a sixth narrative field. It is a number: 2 = followed written rules, 1 = hesitated or late, 0 = broke a rule or peeked. Score it before you look at the next candles if you can; never upgrade it because the trade worked. That is the same decision-quality discipline with a timer.

Ninety-second protocol

  1. 0–15s — Frame and Intent. If you cannot name the rule set, the decision was improvisation. Score 0 and stop.
  2. 15–40s — Tape. Pick from the closed list. “Looks like Nifty wants up” is not a tag.
  3. 40–60s — Urge. If you claim none after a chase candle, you are lying to the template. The template does not argue. It records.
  4. 60–80s — Process 0–2. Outcome (win/loss/skip) can be noted but must not edit process.
  5. 80–90s — Next. Either hold-rule or one tweak for the following decision, not a new strategy.

If the timer hits ninety and Next is blank, write hold-rule. Blank Next is how debriefs become strategy meetings.

A filled example (hypothetical replay)

Hidden-date, liquid large-cap, opening window, pullback-long rules only.

  • Frame: pullback / 09:15–10:15
  • Intent: enter
  • Tape: drive
  • Urge: chase (third strong bar; you still clicked)
  • Process: 0 (rule required a pause bar)
  • Next: no-entry-on-third-bar

Outcome later: the move continued. That sentence does not get to live in the debrief. If you let it in, you will practise chasing.

Second decision, same session:

  • Frame: pullback / 09:15–10:15
  • Intent: skip
  • Tape: unclear
  • Urge: boredom
  • Process: 2
  • Next: hold-rule

That skip is a complete debrief. Empty blotters can still be full templates.

What FIT-UN is for (and not for)

It is for catching repeated Urge × Tape pairs. If chase × drive shows up eight times in a week, your Next line writes itself. If every Next invents a new indicator, you are using the debrief to avoid following the rule you already have.

It is not for:

  • Reconstructing a market narrative (“RBI, FII, Budget”) on a hidden-date chart
  • Computing expectancy from nine trades
  • Arguing with AI review until the machine agrees you were clever. Use automated review, if at all, to flag missing fields — not to override process-0

Failure modes

Essay creep. Frame becomes a paragraph. Cut until it fits one line.

Outcome contamination. You wait until the historical day ends, then debrief with the close in view. That is a review, and it will flatter winners. Debrief at decision time; weekly review can look at outcomes later.

Next-as-reinvention. You change the setup every fourth trade. Cap: one Next change per session, and it applies going forward, not retroactively.

Skip neglect. You only debrief entries. Then patience never appears in the data. Same seriousness for skips.

Indian window blur. You debrief a last-hour square-off decision with an opening-drive Frame. Wrong Frame makes the whole row false.

Batching is allowed only as a fallback. If candle-by-candle debrief breaks your attention on a fast opening drive, park a one-letter Urge (C chase, B boredom, P peek, N none) at decision time and expand to FIT-UN at the session clock-stop — still the same day, still before you look at the full historical close. Expanding tomorrow is how memory writes a kinder story.

Keep FIT-UN in the same note as the trade, not in a separate app you will not open. The template that lives next to the play button is the one you will run on the messy day.

A thirty-day block of roughly ten decisions a day is only useful if those rows exist. Ninety seconds × ten is fifteen minutes of debrief, not a second job. If that feels too heavy, your fields are too long — not the idea.

Debrief the next decision in ninety seconds using FIT-UN, including the skip you wanted to ignore. Join the waitlist.

Educational note

Educational practice content only. Not investment advice. No guaranteed returns. Practice ≠ live profitability.