Traders pick a personality. High win rate, tight target, feel like a surgeon. Or wide target, fewer trophies, feel like a hunter. Then they switch personalities mid-trade when the open profit itches. That is not a tradeoff. That is two unfinished experiments.
The Twin Target Protocol runs the same setup twice: Version Tight and Version Wide. You compare how you behave, and you use only labelled hypothetical arithmetic to remember that win rate and average win are not independent knobs.
The tradeoff in arithmetic — not in your last week
Assume, for illustration only, that losses are −1R when the stop is honoured, and that wins equal the planned target. These are classroom numbers, not observed NSE frequencies, not anyone's results.
Expectancy per trade, as a definition:
(win fraction × average win in R) + (loss fraction × average loss in R)
If average loss is −1R:
| Classroom plan | Hypothetical win fraction | Average win | Illustrative expectancy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tight | 50% | +1R | (0.50\times1 + 0.50\times(-1) = 0) |
| Wide | 40% | +2R | (0.40\times2 + 0.60\times(-1) = +0.20R) |
| Very tight | 60% | +0.8R | (0.60\times0.8 + 0.40\times(-1) = +0.08R) |
| Stretch | 35% | +2.5R | (0.35\times2.5 + 0.65\times(-1) = +0.225R) |
Breakeven win fraction if losses are −1R and wins are a fixed +RR:
1 / (1 + RR)
So +1R needs 50%, +1.5R needs 40%, +2R needs one-third (33.3%), +3R needs 25%. That is rearrangement of the same classroom equation. It is not a forecast of how often a pullback on a large-cap cash name will hit 2R before −1R.
Two honest implications:
- A higher win rate with a smaller target can still lose in R. A lower win rate with a larger target can still lose in R. Neither shape is virtuous.
- You cannot steal the win rate of Tight and the average win of Wide. That hybrid exists only in screenshots.
Paper trading win rates mislead for a related reason: the binary trophy is the easiest number to inflate. Expectancy thinking is the slower, less flattering lens — and even then only on your log, never on these classroom rows.
Version Tight versus Version Wide
Same entry rule. Same stop rule. Same 1R. Same liquidity tier. Same session window. The only legal difference is the exit.
Version Tight. Target at +1R, or the nearest structure that is at least +1R and not more than +1.2R. If no such structure exists, skip. No trail. No partial.
Version Wide. Target at +2R, or the nearest structure at least +2R and not more than +2.4R. If none, skip. No trail. No partial. No "I'll see."
If you need partials or trails to feel sane, you are not ready for this comparison. Those are other articles. Mixing them here produces a third version you will call whichever name is winning.
Decision criteria, before you pick a version for live later (you may never pick either):
| Criterion | Favours Tight in practice | Favours Wide in practice |
|---|---|---|
| You abandon trades when open profit wiggles | Tight, because the wait is shorter | Wide will manufacture relief-exit tags |
| You chase because 1R "isn't worth it" | Tight will feel pointless; fix 1R rupees, don't widen fantasy targets | Wide only if the extra R is a real level |
| NSE window | Midday compression often cannot host 2R without fiction | Opening drive sometimes overshoots 1R quickly — still not a promise |
| Clock | Intraday cash into 15:00 often kills Wide | Delivery/swing can host Wide on daily structure — separate card |
| Review honesty | Easier sample of binary outcomes | More skipped days; do not pad with B-grades |
Twin Target Protocol (four weeks, not a montage)
Weeks 1–2: Tight only, 20 entries on random hidden-date NSE charts, candle by candle.
Weeks 3–4: Wide only, 20 new dates, same setup definition.
Keep a skip log. Tight will skip fewer "no 1R structure" cases; Wide will skip more. If you then complain that Wide "missed trades," you are describing the filter you wrote.
After both blocks, fill this — from your log only, no imported guru percentages:
| Field | Tight | Wide |
|---|---|---|
| Entries taken | ||
| Stops honoured (Y/N count) | ||
| Relief exits before target | ||
| Target hits | ||
| Mean realised R (descriptive) | ||
| Rule-break tags |
You may say: "I honour Tight stops more often" or "I cannot sit for Wide without peeking." Those are fit findings. You may not say: "Wide has edge" from 20 trades. Sample size confidence exists specifically to stop that sentence.
Classroom reminder if you catch yourself combining columns: suppose Tight's hypothetical 50% at 1R and Wide's hypothetical 40% at 2R were both true in a made-up universe. Mixing them into "I win 50% and take 2R" is not a universe. It is a spreadsheet crime.
Indian-market notes the tradeoff usually skips
Open versus lunch. A 2R target from a 9:25 entry on a volatile name can be a nearby round number. The same 2R from a 12:40 range break may sit beyond the day's already-printed high. If you force Wide in a compressed cash session, you are not "being a hunter." You are inventing a level. Tag R-fiction the way risk-reward practice already asks.
Index-driven stocks. Your 1R stop can be noise from a Nifty swing while your 2R target assumes the stock will detach. Practise on names you would hypothetically fill; still do not treat any name as a tip. If the stock is a beta toy, say so in the log.
Costs. Two 1R wins that are 0.3% of price can vanish live after brokerage, STT and slippage. Replay will still show +1R. Mark cost-blind on Tight blocks especially. Wide does not magically include costs either; it only has more room before friction dominates — sometimes. Never quote a cost figure you have not looked up for your own broker.
Thinking in R keeps the comparison sane when Tight's rupee target looks "too small" to bother with. If 1R is ₹2,500 hypothetical, Tight's win is ₹2,500 before friction, not "nothing." If that rupee 1R is too small to care about, you chose the wrong 1R, not the wrong target philosophy. Translate with R-multiple thinking.
Limits
This protocol does not rank strategies. It does not produce a win-rate promise. It will not survive if you trail Tight "just this once" or cut Wide at +0.7R because a news headline crossed the screen.
Replay Trader's hidden dates stop you from picking the trend day for Wide and the mean-reverting day for Tight. That cheat is the usual way the tradeoff "proves" whichever identity you already like.
Run one target law until the log is boring. Then run the other. Join the waitlist.
Related reading
- Expectancy Thinking for Practice Traders
- Risk-Reward Practice: Designing Trades Before Entry
- Why Paper Trading Win Rates Mislead
- Thinking in R Instead of Rupees
Educational note
Educational practice content only. Not investment advice. No guaranteed returns. Practice ≠ live profitability.